Other tenants at Pond Road Plaza include DSW, Michael’s and Petco.
The Trader Joe's store is expected to move into 12,588-square-feet of vacated space previously occupied by Walgreens. The pharmacy closed in 2015.
It was previously reported the company was interested in expanding into the Monmouth County town as early as the fall. Trader Joe's already operates a store on Broad Street in Shrewsbury.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Middletown and receive free news updates.